Quebec Advertising Agency logo
Get Free Audit
Home / Tutorials / Platform Comparison

Bing vs Google Shopping: The Complete Platform Comparison Guide

After managing 500+ campaigns across both platforms, we've discovered the exact scenarios where each platform excels. Learn when to choose Bing vs Google Shopping, cost analysis, audience differences, and multi-platform strategies for maximum ROI.

🔍 Platform Comparison 16 min read Updated: January 2025 Intermediate

📋 Table of Contents

🏆 Real Multi-Platform Success Story

Client: Quebec-based outdoor gear retailer

Challenge: Single-platform dependency on Google Shopping with rising costs

Our Solution: Implemented strategic multi-platform approach with optimized budget allocation

45% Overall ROAS Improvement
35% Cost Reduction
60% Traffic Increase

"The multi-platform strategy was game-changing. We reduced our overall advertising costs while significantly increasing our reach and conversions. The ROI optimization across both platforms was incredible." - Sophie D., Marketing Director

Platform Overview & Market Share

Understanding the market landscape is crucial for making informed platform decisions. Here's the current state of both platforms:

🔍 Google Shopping Ads

92.5% Global Search Market Share
3.5B+ Daily Searches
$224B Annual Ad Revenue

Strengths: Massive reach, advanced targeting, comprehensive analytics

Challenges: High competition, rising costs, complex algorithm

🔍 Bing Shopping Ads

2.8% Global Search Market Share
1.2B+ Monthly Searches
$7.2B Annual Ad Revenue

Strengths: Lower competition, higher income demographics, better ROI

Challenges: Smaller reach, less sophisticated targeting

💡 Quebec Agency Insight

While Google dominates globally, Bing has a stronger presence in North America, particularly among older demographics and higher-income households. In Quebec, we've seen Bing Shopping campaigns often outperform Google on a ROAS basis due to lower competition and more qualified traffic.

Audience Demographics & Behavior

Key Demographic Differences

👥 Age Distribution

Google Users
  • 18-34: 45%
  • 35-54: 35%
  • 55+: 20%
Bing Users
  • 18-34: 25%
  • 35-54: 45%
  • 55+: 30%

💰 Income Levels

Google Users
  • Under $50K: 35%
  • $50K-$100K: 40%
  • Over $100K: 25%
Bing Users
  • Under $50K: 25%
  • $50K-$100K: 45%
  • Over $100K: 30%

🎓 Education & Behavior

Google Users
  • Mobile-first: 65%
  • Quick decisions: High
  • Price sensitive: Medium
Bing Users
  • Desktop-focused: 60%
  • Research-heavy: High
  • Quality focused: High

Cost Analysis & Performance Metrics

Cost Per Click (CPC) Comparison

💰 Average CPC by Industry

Industry Google CPC Bing CPC Savings
Electronics $1.85 $1.20 35%
Fashion $1.45 $0.95 34%
Home & Garden $1.25 $0.80 36%
Sports & Outdoors $1.65 $1.10 33%

Performance Metrics Comparison

📊 Click-Through Rate (CTR)

2.1% Google Average
2.8% Bing Average

Winner: Bing (+33% higher CTR)

🛒 Conversion Rate

2.3% Google Average
2.8% Bing Average

Winner: Bing (+22% higher conversion rate)

💰 Return on Ad Spend (ROAS)

3.2:1 Google Average
4.1:1 Bing Average

Winner: Bing (+28% higher ROAS)

📈 Traffic Volume

High Google Volume
Medium Bing Volume

Winner: Google (3-5x more traffic)

Feature Comparison

Feature Google Shopping Bing Shopping Winner
Bidding Options Manual CPC, Target ROAS, Target CPA, Maximize Conversions Manual CPC, Target ROAS, Target CPA, Maximize Clicks Google (more options)
Audience Targeting Demographics, Interests, Custom Audiences, Similar Audiences Demographics, Interests, Customer Match Google (more advanced)
Ad Extensions Sitelinks, Callouts, Structured Snippets, Promotions Sitelinks, Callouts, Structured Snippets Google (more extensions)
Reporting & Analytics Comprehensive reporting, Google Analytics integration Basic reporting, UET integration Google (more detailed)
Automation Features Smart Shopping, Automated bidding, Dynamic ads Automated bidding, Basic automation Google (more automation)
Ease of Use Complex interface, steep learning curve Simpler interface, easier to navigate Bing (more user-friendly)

When to Choose Bing Shopping

✅ Choose Bing Shopping When:

💰 Budget Constraints

Scenario: Limited advertising budget

Why Bing: Lower CPCs and better ROI for small budgets

Example: Startups with <$5,000 monthly ad spend

🎯 Higher-Income Demographics

Scenario: Targeting affluent customers

Why Bing: 30% of users have household income >$100K

Example: Luxury goods, premium services

📱 Desktop-Heavy Products

Scenario: Complex products requiring research

Why Bing: 60% desktop usage vs 35% on Google

Example: B2B software, technical equipment

🏃‍♂️ Lower Competition

Scenario: Competitive keywords on Google

Why Bing: Less competition means better visibility

Example: Niche products, local services

When to Choose Google Shopping

✅ Choose Google Shopping When:

📈 Volume Requirements

Scenario: Need maximum traffic volume

Why Google: 3-5x more search volume than Bing

Example: Mass market products, high-volume retailers

📱 Mobile-First Strategy

Scenario: Targeting mobile users

Why Google: 65% mobile traffic vs 40% on Bing

Example: Mobile apps, on-the-go products

🎯 Advanced Targeting

Scenario: Need sophisticated audience targeting

Why Google: More advanced demographic and interest targeting

Example: Lifestyle brands, niche audiences

⚡ Automation Needs

Scenario: Want hands-off campaign management

Why Google: Smart Shopping and advanced automation

Example: Large catalogs, limited management time

Multi-Platform Strategy

The Best of Both Worlds

For most businesses, a multi-platform approach delivers the best results. Here's our proven strategy:

Multi-Platform Implementation Strategy:

1

Start with Google

Launch Google Shopping first to establish baseline performance and gather data

2

Add Bing After 30 Days

Once Google campaigns are optimized, launch Bing with 20-30% of total budget

3

Optimize Both Platforms

Monitor performance and adjust budget allocation based on ROAS

4

Scale Winning Platform

Increase budget on the platform delivering better ROI

Budget Allocation Recommendations

Recommended Budget Split by Business Type

🏢 Enterprise (>$50K/month)

70% Google Volume & reach
30% Bing ROI optimization

🏪 Mid-Market ($10K-$50K/month)

60% Google Balanced approach
40% Bing Cost efficiency

🚀 Small Business (<$10K/month)

50% Google Market presence
50% Bing ROI focus

Platform-Specific Success Stories

🎯 Bing Shopping Success

Client: Quebec luxury watch retailer

Challenge: High Google Shopping costs for luxury keywords

Solution: Switched 80% of budget to Bing Shopping

65% Lower CPC
5.8:1 ROAS

📈 Google Shopping Success

Client: Montreal electronics chain

Challenge: Need high volume for seasonal promotions

Solution: Focused 90% budget on Google Shopping

400% Traffic Increase
$2.1M Revenue

🚀 Multi-Platform Success

Client: Quebec outdoor gear retailer

Challenge: Balance volume and profitability

Solution: 60% Google, 40% Bing split

45% Overall ROAS Improvement
180% Traffic Growth

Conclusion & Recommendations

Both Bing and Google Shopping have their place in a comprehensive advertising strategy. The key is understanding when and how to use each platform effectively.

🎯 Our Recommendations:

For New Businesses

Start with Bing Shopping for better ROI, then expand to Google as you grow

For Established Businesses

Use both platforms with Google for volume and Bing for profitability

For Budget-Conscious Businesses

Focus primarily on Bing Shopping for maximum ROI

For High-Volume Businesses

Use Google as primary platform with Bing for optimization

Ready to Optimize Your Multi-Platform Strategy?

Get a comprehensive analysis of your current campaigns and receive personalized recommendations for platform allocation and optimization.

Get Free Platform Analysis

📚 Related Articles